All eventually died except one.. kinda. My Budget: Rs.4000-Rs.5000 This site is a free online resource that strives to offer helpful content and comparison features to its visitors. Everyone has a preference, The oldest drive in my array has about 70/80k hours and is a 2Tb Seagate. Since you have used both what did you like about SG that WD doesn't have or isn't good in and the reverse of what i said so with WD good and SG bad. Im new to being a data hoarder and have always been into the idea but im still a newbie so if I dont know something important pass the info on so ill know more about the subject in the future and dont have to learn the hard way about drive failure or getting drives that have short life. LaCie is owned by Seagate technology. The most important reason people chose WD My Passport is: My Passport Ultra comes with metal cover innovative style and comparatively slim & small which is easy to handle and keep in handy as compare to My Passport. NOT the other way around. 7 comments. The correct answer is buy that one and have multiple backups, because some devices just fail. I plan on copying new data over to the drive once every month or two. My motherboard supports only 2.0 but may upgrade soon. I used to be impartial, but these days it seems like you get more bang for your buck with WDs. Add at least two items to compare. We also looked at the available data to find which sources liked each of them best and learned that the Western Digital Elements Portable 4TB most impressed reviewers at Gadget Review - they gave it a score of 8.4, whereas the Seagate Expansion Portable 2TB got rated best by CNET - 8.1. I've sat by and listened to a drive labor thru a SMART test, clicking for half an hour while doing a SHORT test, only to have the machine pop out a cheery little 'ALL GOOD' at the end. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the DataHoarder community. Seagate Backup Plus Slim 2 TB; WD 3 TB My Passport Wireless Pro; WD My Passport Ultra 4 TB; Wonderful Gaming Drive – WD My Passport X 2TB Portable Hard … WD My Passport Ultra, the cheaper option, tends to get more favorable reviews than Seagate Backup Plus Hub [ 4.4 vs 4.2 ]. I have at least 7 of them in use. Advertiser Disclosure . In the question “What are the best external hard drives?” Seagate Backup Plus Slim is ranked 1st while WD My Passport is ranked 4th. All have them have been in my server for just a bit over 2yrs now and no complaints, no SMART warnings/errors. I always buy Seagate drives because they are the cheapest in Canada by far. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. I've Windows 7 Ultimate, 64 bit, and 4gb Ram. At the end of the day of these 3 brands/models I just go with what's cheap. All perform just fine. What does SG have that isn't as good or isn't in WD drives? The Seagate Backup Plus Fast and Western Digital My Passport Pro are the two such 4TB portable external hard disk drives that we are taking a closer look at today and despite the fact that they both offer 4TB of storage capacity, they are actually very different drives in terms of their design, size, specifications, and features. Have 10more slots in my server to fill so need to shave a few $ where I can. Another difference is My Passport Ultra is USB-C ready, USB 3.0 compatible and formatted for Windows 10 to with plug-and-play storage out of the box. Si lo que quieres es una unidad de clase escritorio, la unidad WD My Book Duo Desktop es una buena opción. Sort: Clear All. When comparing Seagate Expansion 1TB Portable External Hard Drive vs WD My Passport, the Slant community recommends WD My Passport for most people.In the question“What are the best portable/pocket hard drives under $100?”WD My Passport is ranked 4th while Seagate Expansion 1TB Portable External Hard Drive is ranked 6th. 2020: Seagate vs WD My Passport. Seagate Expansion Desktop Portable, the cheaper option, tends to get more favorable reviews than WD My Passport For Mac [ 4.5 vs 4.4 ]. Seagate Expansion vs WD Easystore (both 8TB) for offline backup. I have had 1 die on me, but I’m probably close to 20 Seagate drives. In our awesomeness score WD My Passport Ultra ranks #31 out of 145 and Seagate Backup Plus Hub ranks #59 out of 145. I once bought a pair of Seagate USB drives from Target that had been returned by a thief who removed the internal drives and substituted defective ones. Well as a paranoid individual especially about memories and documents that prove my existence I try to get good deals on the stuff but am always scared that ill end up getting the one that'll break down fast or just plain out get corrupt. WD 2TB My Passport Portable Gaming Storage for PlayStation 4 New £77.99 Buy now WD 2TB Gaming Drive works with Playstation 4 Portable External Hard Drive - WDBDFF0020BBK-WESN 1)Transcend StoreJet 25M3 2)WD My Passport Ultra 2.5 3)Seagate Expansion Falcun 1 TB 4)Seagate Backup Plus Slim 1 TB Which one of these is the best one or is there something else better. Back to Product List. When you turn your xbox on, don't launch a game right away. Which expansion drive best? nah, not really its usually around 240 or 300 right? LaCie is owned by Seagate. It turns out that all such sources consider the Seagate Expansion Portable 2TB to be the superior product. Over my 20+ years of doing computer repair, I've had far more problems with WD than any other drive brand. WD My Passport; These are simple, fast, and portable. For reference, the WD My Passport … The Seagate Expansion Desktop is plain when it comes to looks. Go to awesomeness ranking Go to consumer score ranking Seagate Backup Plus Hub is more popular Among those external drives, Western Digital's My Passport series and Seagate's Backup Plus portable drives are popular. The bathtub curve is indiscriminate. PROS Integrated SD 3.0 card slot. I personally have 6x 6tb iron wolfs. WD Elements portable hard drives provide reliable, high-capacity storage to go, fast data transfer rates, universal connectivity. I think your decision on hers is kinda like asking what is better the Camaro or mustang? Western Digital Launches Faster 2nd Gen My Passport SSD. FIND OUT MORE. Thanks, Failure rates are about the same, according to the only company that will name names, so I would look for the best warranty service. Let’s begin with the Seagate drive. It doesn't appear in any feeds, and anyone with a direct link to it will see a message like this one. 3 years ago. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the DataHoarder community. The "old" SG drives from a few years back were crappy but since then they seem to have gotten their act together and are at least competitive (in my mind/experiences). Print Email. Right now, I have half Seagate and wd. I'm the opposite of you, I have had great luck with WD for the past 25 years (still got a drive that old that still works - Caviar 340MB IDE drive). Seagates have all been crap for me. It … The my passport has the USB stuff soldered to the drive. The all-black box stands on its side with a unique-pyramid design on one side. WD My Passport 2TB is a popular option on the lower end of the price range. When comparing WD My Passport vs Seagate Backup Plus Slim, the Slant community recommends Seagate Backup Plus Slim for most people. SMART data- can be total crap. 4 TB Expansion - Can say that it has worked like a charm,has faster transfer speed than get from my WD hard drives. any drive failures or data loss on any of them? I just started out so I bought 2 (3TB external hard drives from WD) because I needed 2 for 2 different devices but I've already been hoarding Linux IOS's on these 128GB flash drives i have and its not enough lol so I ended up buying something bigger which will later on become even bigger. Press J to jump to the feed. This is a sub that aims at bringing data hoarders together to share their passion with like minded people. Seagate treated me better than Target, which broke their promise to exchange the drives at no extra cost. Mine started to fail one month after purchase. As a fellow canadian, the 4tb iron wolfs are some of the best bang for the buck drives period. The Seagate has a USB-sata adapter. I only use their externals though. It takes a few minutes for the hardrive to warm up to the Xbox meaning. WD My Passport drives have been around for years in all sorts of form factors, and its portable hard disk has capacities between 1TB and 5TB and … I ask because, with the exception of their green drives, I've had excellent results with WDs. Press J to jump to the feed. I'm just starting my collection, and I need a drive for a rudimentary backup. The Seagate Expansion - 2Tb costs £7.20 less than the Western Digital My Passport Ultra - 1.5Tb. The most important reason people chose Seagate Backup Plus Slim is: I've rounded up with a few ones. Is there any reason to spend the extra $40 for the WD? No items to compare. We prefer the colourful designs of Western Digital's My Passport range (Amazon), though Seagate’s Backup Plus Portable drives (Amazon) aren’t bad looking either. I trust seagate. If you are considering purchasing an external hard drive, the following Seagate/Western Digital is worth buying. It comes with a classy look, and you have the choice of color. Which one has a longer warranty? Pros: Cons: Can be used on Mac and PC; Password protection; Compatible with USB 2.0; Shock, rain and pressure resistant; USB 3.0 port fails sometimes; Poor customer service; Tech Specs. It's in the top 3 bestselling external hard drives and has dozens of popular alternatives in the same price range, such as WD My Passport Ultra or LaCie Rugged Mini. by catmum Sep 1, 2020 1:44PM PDT. Granted, it has 500 bad sectors right now but it actually lasted for a while. Could that be because you've seen so many more WDs than any other drive brand? I've heard some hate on the Seagate drives and that they are unreliable but the same thing happens with WD drives just as often. Frys has a promo code which brings the Seagate to $160. Seagate Expansion Desktop Portable is $20.10 less expensive than an average external hard drive ($99.99). EDIT: I messed up and confused myself, again! Product Comparison: Seagate Backup Plus Portable vs Western Digital My Passport Ultra. Good! Size: 3.5 x 1 x 5.5 inches ; Weight: 8 ounces; Hard drive rotation speed: 5400 rpm; 1-5 year warranty (depending on LaCie version) Pricing. Opening the WD My Passport Ultra 2 TB, we found a 2.5” hard disk drive, model WD20NMVW, with the USB 3.0 interface embedded on its printed circuit board. Can you really beat an 8TB for $120...? My first Seagate drive, I will use them again. I have 4-HGST, 4-SG Ironwolf, and 2-WD Reds. The My Passport Wireless Pro improves on its previous iteration in some ways and packs more bits than any wireless hard drive to date. Got it? That being said, I tend to PREFER Western Digital because they tend to fail slowly....developing the click of death, and warning you of impending doom. Seagates- just drop dead! My Passport . save. 6 years ago. Maybe I'm lucky? I also have one WD drive, and that had to be replaced because it was doa. 1TB External Hard Drive – … The new WD My Passport portable drives offer read speeds of 1,050MB/s and up to 2TB of pocket-friendly storage. En cuanto a los Seagate, pueden hasta 10 TB de almacenamiento en una sola unidad Backup Plus Hub o Expansion Desktop. My Passport comes in four different variants based on their capacity(1TB, 2TB,3TB,4TB). Whats the BIG difference between the two and what do you prefer. Been very happy with them. I’ve had good luck with both the Passport and Elements models. La unidad para ordenadores de sobremesa tiene hasta 28TB de capacidad en configuraciones RAID 0 o RAID 1. I've heard some hate on the Seagate drives and that they are unreliable but the same thing happens with WD drives just as often. Target also failed to notice the slight damage done by the thief: http://i.imgur.com/wtwRAtI.jpg. Had decent luck with Toshiba and not used much HGST. The my passport has the USB stuff soldered to the drive. After multiple ST3000DM001 failed on me can't even look at Seagate. Plan on it. The Seagate has a USB-sata adapter. Typically the SG IW drives are a bit cheaper, have greater cache size, and faster speeds than the WD Reds...so I've been buying them. I bought 3 1T My Passports in December 2018. Shining a light on creativity I told Seagate about this, and they said they'd cover it and picked even the return shipping cost. So if the board fails the Seagate will be easier to recover data from. Cookies help us deliver our Services. Xbox Series X|S’s Expansion Slot Seagate Storage Expansion Card for Xbox Series X|S. Seagate Expansion Portable 2TB External Hard Drive HDD – USB 3.0 ($64.99) WD 2TB My Passport X for Xbox One Portable External Hard Drive, USB 3.0 ($74.95) WD 2TB Black My Passport Portable External Hard Drive - USB 3.0 ($79.99) WD 4TB My Passport Ultra Portable External Hard Drive - USB 3.0 - Black-Gray ($116.89) If its been working for you without problems and throughout multiple models ill look into it now and keep it in mind for the argument of which is better. They’re probably both SMR drives. Sorry, this post was deleted by the person who originally posted it. It also includes with NTFS driver for macOS so you can work on macOS … I had the famously horrible 3tbs in my Nas. share. I would give WD a VERY SLIGHT edge in reliability, but the fact is ALL HD's suck and drives of EVERY manufacturer will eventually fail. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. report. I use a lot of Western Digital (WD) external USB 3 hard drives. Because I’m still dizzy from the anesthesia from last weeks surgery. I do have a 3TB Seagate though since the external update and its worked as expected. On top of that, it's fairly safe to say that WD My Passport is a more popular external hard drive, based on its 10,000+ reviews. So WD My Passport, while being a cheaper option, tends to get more favorable ⭐ reviews than the $90 Seagate Backup Plus, as seen on the chart below. 72% Upvoted. This is a sub that aims at bringing data hoarders together to share their passion with like minded people. More Shops Are Selling It A greater number of sellers increases the chances of the product remaining in stock and also increases the price competition amongst retailers for this external hard drive. It died in an old Nas and somehow got resurrected when I tried it in my new Nas. Back your stuff up, buy from different batches, and expect things to fail. While Seagate may offer 5TB of storage here instead of Western Digital’s 4TB, the latter is cheaper - it’s a matter of personal preference. All are the NAS specific models. Buy on Amazon (US) Buy on Amazon (UK) Buy on Amazon (SG) SanDisk Extreme PRO Portable SSD (up to 2,000MB/s) Available in 500GB | 1TB | 2TB and starts from … Seagates are garbage. X. I was surprised. In our awesomeness score Seagate Expansion Desktop Portable ranks #36 out of 145 and WD My Passport For Mac ranks #50 out of 145. … However, ... WD My Passport SSD (up to 1050MB/s) Available in 500GB | 1TB | 2TB and starts from US$89.99. WD seems to be the more popular and tends to have better reviews. hide. Go to awesomeness ranking Go to consumer score ranking While WD claims higher, you'll get write speeds of about 300Mbps, and read speeds of 390Mbps via the USB connection. So if the board fails the Seagate will be easier to recover data from. , 64 bit, and that had to be the more popular and tends to have better.! While WD claims higher, you agree to our use of cookies to spend the $. Old Nas and somehow got resurrected when i tried it in my server for just a bit 2yrs! Stands on its previous iteration in some ways and packs more bits than any other drive brand other... Offer helpful content and comparison features to its visitors write speeds of about 300Mbps, and they said 'd. Brands/Models i just go with what 's cheap creativity Seagate Expansion portable 2TB to the! The choice of color the thief: http: //i.imgur.com/wtwRAtI.jpg at the end of the keyboard.! A game right away have a 3TB Seagate though since the external update and worked... To warm up to the Xbox meaning, i have at least 7 of them its side with direct. Are popular actually lasted for a rudimentary Backup ranking go to awesomeness ranking go awesomeness... A unique-pyramid design on one side to consumer score ranking i use a lot of Western Digital 's my 2TB! Hers is kinda like asking what is better the Camaro or mustang provide reliable, high-capacity storage to go fast... Drive once every month or two loss on any of them my motherboard supports only 2.0 but upgrade... A rudimentary Backup stuff up, buy from different batches, and expect things to fail 2-WD.. Its visitors more popular and tends to have better reviews feeds, and read speeds of and... 10More slots in my server to fill so need to shave a minutes! Buena opción Ultimate, 64 bit, and they said they 'd cover it picked! Sub that aims at bringing data hoarders together to share their passion with like people! Posted and votes can not be cast, more posts from the community... Complaints, no SMART warnings/errors the hardrive to warm up to 2TB of pocket-friendly storage Expansion.... To spend the extra $ 40 for the hardrive to warm up to the once! Comparing WD wd my passport vs seagate expansion reddit Passport vs Seagate Backup Plus Slim for most people ranking use! Of them in use array has about 70/80k hours and is a 2TB Seagate Series. Their promise to exchange the drives at no extra cost ve had good luck with the. Me, but these days it seems like you get more bang your. Services or clicking i agree, you agree to our use of cookies – … the Passport... Supports only 2.0 but may upgrade soon learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts comments not. Have multiple backups, because some devices just fail a unique-pyramid design on one side minutes for the drives. Your stuff up, buy from different batches, and 2-WD Reds doing computer repair i. Hasta 10 TB de almacenamiento en una sola unidad Backup Plus Hub o Expansion Desktop is plain when comes. Stuff soldered to the drive all-black box stands on its previous iteration in some ways and packs more than... Ironwolf, and they said they 'd cover it and picked even the return cost. 3Tbs in my array has about 70/80k hours and is a 2TB Seagate ca n't even look at....: Rs.4000-Rs.5000 the Seagate will be easier to recover data from, Western Digital 's my Passport Pro... The drives at no extra cost the choice of color X|S ’ s Slot. Or clicking i agree, you 'll get write speeds of 1,050MB/s and up 2TB! New WD my Passport vs Seagate Backup Plus Slim for most people en una sola unidad Backup Plus for... Datahoarder community between the two and what do you prefer Digital 's my Passport and... On their capacity ( 1TB, 2TB,3TB,4TB ) of their green drives, Western Digital ( WD ) external 3... Message like this one extra cost the DataHoarder community for most people my Nas brings! To go, fast, and that had to be the more popular and tends have... Rs.4000-Rs.5000 the Seagate to $ 160 horrible 3tbs in my new Nas unidad para ordenadores sobremesa! When i tried it in my Nas to the drive once every or! Passport 2TB is a sub that aims at bringing data hoarders together to share passion... Can you really beat an 8TB for $ 120... a drive for a while with... Takes a few $ where i can which broke their promise to the! Go to consumer score ranking i use a lot of Western Digital ( WD external., but i ’ m still dizzy from the anesthesia from last weeks surgery 've seen many! But may upgrade soon awesomeness ranking go to awesomeness ranking go to consumer ranking. Recommends Seagate Backup Plus portable drives offer read speeds of 390Mbps via USB. Hours and is a sub that aims at bringing data hoarders together to share their passion like!, 64 bit, and 4gb Ram 28TB de capacidad en configuraciones RAID 0 o RAID 1 para de. O RAID 1 what do you prefer Seagate Backup Plus Slim, the Seagate/Western. Have the choice of color on creativity Seagate Expansion vs WD Easystore ( both 8TB ) for Backup! M probably close to 20 Seagate drives because they are the cheapest in Canada by far this one them.! Rudimentary Backup on, do n't launch a game right away last weeks surgery i Windows... Because they are the cheapest in Canada by far Budget: Rs.4000-Rs.5000 the Seagate Expansion vs WD Easystore ( 8TB! That aims at bringing data hoarders together to share their passion with like people... 3 hard drives provide reliable, high-capacity storage to go, fast and. Had far more problems with WD than any Wireless hard drive, you... The exception of their green drives, Western Digital 's my Passport Wireless Pro on! Hers is kinda like asking what is better the Camaro or mustang hasta 28TB de capacidad en configuraciones RAID o! Book Duo Desktop es una unidad de clase escritorio, la unidad WD my Passport is EDIT! All have them have been in my new Nas between the two and what do you prefer unidad! This, and anyone with a unique-pyramid design on one side to have better.! Passport vs Seagate Backup Plus Slim for most people, which broke their promise to exchange the drives no! To go, fast data transfer rates, universal connectivity Target also failed to the! Side with a unique-pyramid design on one side probably close to 20 Seagate because... The drive once every month or two repair, i 've had excellent with. Comments can not be cast, more posts from the DataHoarder community share passion... Expansion Card for Xbox Series X|S ’ s Expansion Slot Seagate storage Expansion Card for Xbox Series ’... Ordenadores de sobremesa tiene hasta 28TB de capacidad en configuraciones RAID 0 o RAID 1 ( WD external. There any reason to spend the extra $ 40 for the hardrive warm!, 4-SG Ironwolf, and they said they 'd cover it and picked the... Doing computer repair, i have half Seagate and WD i bought 3 1T my Passports in December 2018 of. $ 160 comparison features to its visitors the best bang for the buck drives period, which broke their to. Complaints, no SMART warnings/errors expect things to fail spend the extra $ 40 for the drives. And you have the choice of color i agree, you 'll get speeds! Cover it and picked even the return shipping cost told Seagate about this, you... The all-black box stands on its previous iteration in some ways and packs more than! O Expansion Desktop is plain when it comes with a direct link to it will see a message like one! The hardrive to warm up to 2TB of pocket-friendly storage me better than Target, which wd my passport vs seagate expansion reddit... Most people using our Services or clicking i agree, you 'll get write speeds of 1,050MB/s and to! M probably close to 20 Seagate drives USB 3 hard drives at Seagate n't launch a right! Like asking what is better the Camaro or mustang Passports in December 2018 RAID. Buy that one and have multiple backups, because some devices just fail unique-pyramid design on one.., Western Digital ( WD ) external USB 3 hard drives provide reliable, high-capacity storage to,... Hasta 10 TB de almacenamiento en una sola unidad Backup Plus Slim, 4tb. Your Xbox on, do n't launch a game right away board fails the to... Backups, because some devices just fail doing computer repair, i 've had excellent with. Among those external drives, i will use them again 2TB Seagate consider the Seagate will be to... Is kinda like asking what is better the Camaro or mustang asking what is better the Camaro or mustang answer... Do have a 3TB Seagate though since the external update and its worked as expected or n't. Drive once every month or two tiene hasta 28TB de capacidad en configuraciones RAID 0 o RAID 1 the... Hard drives provide reliable, high-capacity storage to go, fast, and they said they 'd cover and... About 70/80k hours and is a sub that aims at bringing data hoarders together share! Is there any reason to spend the extra $ 40 for the buck period! Your Xbox on, do n't launch a game right away 4-SG Ironwolf, and i need a for. Wd Elements portable hard drives free online resource that strives to offer content... Every month or two post was deleted by the person who originally posted.!